Nov 072010
 November 7, 2010  Posted by  Court, Surveillance

It’s nice to see the courts not making excuses for warrantless searches. I suspect Montana law enforcement will be more careful about warrants after having two cases tossed in relatively short order.

Sanjay Talwani reports:

For the second time in a month, the Montana Supreme Court has thrown out a conviction because prosecutors used recordings made by a confidential police informant without a search warrant.

Dallas Edward Reichmand, 53, was found guilty in 2008 in Butte-Silver Bow County for a pair of August 2007 sales of morphine tablets to a police informant who was wearing a recording device.

After that conviction but before sentencing, the high court threw out a different case involving warrantless recordings, citing privacy protections in the Montana Constitution. In a 6-1 decision Oct. 27, it applied that ruling retroactively to the Reichmand case, shooting down the conviction.

Read more in the Helena Independent Record.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.