Aug 152015
 August 15, 2015  Posted by  Featured News, Non-U.S.

India’s national ID system, Aadhaar, has been promoted as ensuring access to public benefits. But from Day One, it has also raised significant privacy and data security concerns, as this blog has tried to point out over the past few years. Today, Malavika Jayaram, a fellow at the Berkman Center, writes about Aadhaar:

Privacy is breached at several levels; at the time of data collection (especially when biometrics are involved); at the time of its storage by multiple actors (which federated and decentralised enrollment apparatus facilitates by design); at the time of use (especially when Aadhaar is tagged for banal everyday activities that are low-risk from an identity theft or benefits fraud point of view, risking an allegedly secure system being devalued through ubiquity, and compromised through biometric overuse). All of this is compounded by the lack of a statutory frame for the Unique Identification Authority of India and/or a dedicated privacy law.

When the Attorney General contends, as he did during the ongoing matter before the Supreme Court, and as referenced in Tuesday’s order, that there is no privacy violation if the data is not shared, this fails to acknowledge the very complex network of transactions and uses that the scheme is predicated on. When the Supreme Court misses the opportunity to put the brakes on the continued collection of data, it opens the door for the government relying on the Too Big To Fail, Too Late to Turn Back rhetoric.


Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.